Tune in as we get REAL about working in schools, serving students, and advocating for our roles. You've never heard school counseling like this.
We LOVE helping school counselors! From interviewing to learning about all the the
things they don't teach in grad school like 504, MTSS, and behavior intervention, we will help you become the most empowered & educated counselor-expert you can be!
When I decided to leave classroom teaching and become a school counselor, I had some pretty ambitious dreams. I was going to help kids. I was going to make a difference. I was going to change lives…. I was also really looking forward to being able to go to the bathroom whenever I wanted.
Seriously, I’m not kidding. After years of needing another adult to supervise 25 students just so I could use the restroom, bathroom autonomy sounded like professional freedom. I pictured a beautiful little counseling office, a schedule full of meaningful student appointments, and the ability to occasionally get up and walk down the hall without asking anyone’s permission. As it turns out, I had a slightly inaccurate picture of what school counseling was going to be like.
Looking back, I can identify six things I believed about this profession that experience eventually taught me to reconsider. Maybe you’ll recognize a few of them.
One: I Thought I’d Be in Charge of My Time
I imagined school counseling would give me more control over my day. I’d have appointments, meetings, student sessions, and enough flexibility to organize things the way I wanted. That’s cute.
A school counselor’s schedule is often more of a suggestion than a commitment. A parent calls. A student needs immediate support. An administrator stops by. Someone needs you in the cafeteria. Suddenly, half the day is gone, and the things you planned to accomplish are still waiting. I had confused having more flexibility with having more control. Those aren’t the same thing.
When everyone assumes you’re automatically available, flexibility can quickly become a lack of boundaries.
Two: I Thought I’d Eventually Get Caught Up
I genuinely believed there would be a day when all the referrals were handled, emails answered, documentation finished, lessons planned, and loose ends tied up. Then I could finally get to the good stuff: the students I wanted to spend more time with and the program improvements I’d been dreaming about.
Apparently, I thought the school would eventually run out of problems. News flash… it doesn’t.
You finish one task, and three more appear. You clear your inbox, and 12 new emails arrive. You organize a small group, and now you have schedules, attendance, teacher communication, and follow-up to manage. For a long time, I treated being perpetually behind as a personal failure. I thought I needed a better system, more organization, or a little more efficiency.
Eventually, I realized I was measuring my success against a condition that didn’t actually exist. There is no magic day when everything is finished and you finally get to do the important work.
That realization is part of what led me to the idea of modulated expectations. We have to adjust what we expect of ourselves to account for the actual conditions we’re working in, not some imaginary version of school counseling where nobody interrupts us and time is unlimited.
Three: I Thought Asking for Help Meant I Wasn’t Good at My Job
This one took me a while to recognize. I had spent years studying counseling theories, human development, assessment, interventions, and ethics. I was supposed to be the person other people came to when they didn’t know what to do.
So what happened when I didn’t know what to do? Apparently, I was supposed to figure it out quietly and hope nobody noticed.
It’s interesting how easily we can believe that consultation is important for everyone else while treating it like a personal weakness when we need it ourselves. Think about other professions. We don’t assume a physician is incompetent because they consult with a specialist. We understand that complicated situations often require multiple perspectives. School counseling shouldn’t be any different.
There’s a difference between asking someone to tell you what to do and consulting with someone to improve your thinking. Good consultation doesn’t take away your professional responsibility. It helps you exercise better judgment. Sometimes someone challenges an assumption you’ve made. Sometimes they help you see a possibility you overlooked. Sometimes they confirm that the situation really is as complicated as you thought.
Needing consultation doesn’t mean you’re failing. It’s part of responsible professional practice.
Four: I Thought Every Student Problem Needed a Counseling Activity
A student is struggling with friendships? Find a friendship activity.
A student is getting frustrated in class? Find an emotional regulation activity.
A student isn’t following directions? Maybe there’s an executive functioning activity for that.
Before you know it, you’ve spent two hours printing, laminating, cutting, sorting, and organizing a $2 resource that may or may not address the actual problem.
Listen, there are good counseling activities out there. The problem is when we start confusing lesson preparation with intervention planning.
The activity isn’t the intervention by itself. What matters is why you’re using it, what you expect it to accomplish, and whether it’s appropriate for the problem you’re trying to address.
Consider a student who struggles to complete independent work. Maybe the student needs counseling support. Maybe they need more direct instruction. Maybe the assignment is beyond their current skill level. Maybe the classroom demands or adult responses need to change. Finding another worksheet doesn’t automatically address any of those things.
Sometimes the most useful contribution a school counselor can make isn’t something they personally deliver to a student. It’s a conversation with a teacher that changes what happens in the classroom.
That’s the second pillar of sanity-based school counseling: consultation. Your expertise doesn’t have to begin and end with something you personally provide.
Five: I Thought Everybody Needed to Like Me
I thought being a good school counselor meant being friendly, approachable, understanding, patient, positive, and generally delightful to be around. Basically, I wanted to be the campus equivalent of a golden retriever.
The problem? I had somehow convinced myself that if I was doing my job well, nobody should ever be unhappy with me. Think about how unrealistic that is in a building full of people who disagree about practically everything. Teachers disagree with teachers. Parents disagree with teachers. Administrators disagree with parents. Students disagree with everybody. Yet somehow, I thought I was supposed to keep everyone happy.
Here’s what took me a while to understand: People can like you and still not respect your professional judgment. They can appreciate everything you do and still have no interest in changing their practices. On the other hand, someone can disagree with you, feel frustrated by your recommendation, or not particularly enjoy a conversation with you while still respecting your expertise.
Relationships matter. Being approachable matters. Being universally liked is not a job requirement. Sometimes doing your job well means saying something another person doesn’t want to hear. You cannot spend your entire career editing your professional perspective to keep everyone happy with you.
Six: I Thought Everyone Would Be Thrilled I’d Arrived
This one might be my favorite. I finished graduate school with all kinds of ideas about leadership, advocacy, collaboration, and systemic change. I was ready to help students, support teachers, work with families, and improve the entire campus. I assumed people would recognize a good idea when they heard one. Surely, if I had evidence supporting a recommendation, everyone would be excited to implement it.
As it turns out, other people already had their own priorities, routines, opinions, and reasons for doing things the way they’d always done them. A good idea can still ask someone else to change something that matters to them.
You might be recommending a different classroom practice, a new intervention, or a change in how a student is supported. You’re thinking about how much better things could be for students. Someone else may be thinking about the additional time, energy, or effort your recommendation requires. Having the facts on your side doesn’t automatically settle that conversation. Neither does your master’s degree or your enthusiasm.
Professional influence is something you develop. It isn’t automatically awarded because you showed up with good ideas. You have to understand how decisions are made, what matters to the people involved, and how to become someone whose professional judgment people actually seek out.
That’s the third pillar of sanity-based school counseling: professional influence.
What I Had to Unlearn About School Counseling
When I look at these six confessions together, I see a common thread. I had a very specific picture of what being a good school counselor was supposed to look like. A good school counselor gets everything done. Knows what to do. Helps every student. Gets along with everybody. Changes things for the better. If I could just become good enough at my job, surely all of those things would eventually fall into place, and that was an expensive assumption.
I eventually needed a different way to approach the profession. One that accounted for the actual conditions I was working in, the people I was working with, and the things I could and couldn’t influence.
That’s where the three pillars of sanity-based school counseling come in:
Sanity-based school counseling isn’t about giving up on what we want the profession to look like. It’s about becoming more effective in the schools we actually work in, with the people we actually work with, and under the circumstances we actually have.
You can spend your entire career trying to make your job match the picture you had in graduate school. Or you can start figuring out how to do really good work in the job that’s right in front of you. That’s where a whole lot of professional growth happens.
If these confessions sound familiar, the S4SC Hub, Mastermind, and Blog offer resources, consultation, and support to help you navigate the realities of this work. You can also explore The Secrets of Sanity-Based School Counseling, the companion resource discussed in this episode.

A space for real relationships, honest collaboration, and practical tools that work.
We don’t sell "cute." We build professionals.
Contact us for information on keynotes, trainings, events, resources and more!
Research & Practice